Monday, November 16, 2026
  • About Us
  • Advertisement
  • Privacy Policy
The Daily Crucible
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
    Binance Buys Back Tokens After $6.3bn Loss in History’s Biggest Heist Linked to North Korean Hackers

    Binance Buys Back Tokens After $6.3bn Loss in History’s Biggest Heist Linked to North Korean Hackers

    Dangote Group Eyes $36bn Revenue as Lamu Refinery Project Advances

    Dangote Group Eyes $36bn Revenue as Lamu Refinery Project Advances

    Don’t Use School Fees or Sell Your House to Buy Dangote Refinery Shares, Emir Sanusi Warns Nigerians

    Don’t Use School Fees or Sell Your House to Buy Dangote Refinery Shares, Emir Sanusi Warns Nigerians

    SEC Warns Investors as Dangote Refinery Opens N2.15tn Share Offer

    SEC Warns Investors as Dangote Refinery Opens N2.15tn Share Offer

    Johnson & Johnson Offers $5.5bn to End 69,000 Lawsuits Over Claims Baby Powder Caused Ovarian Cancer

    Johnson & Johnson Offers $5.5bn to End 69,000 Lawsuits Over Claims Baby Powder Caused Ovarian Cancer

    Lafarge Africa Rebrands As HBM Nigeria Plc, Signals New Era Under Huaxin Ownership

    Lafarge Africa Rebrands As HBM Nigeria Plc, Signals New Era Under Huaxin Ownership

    Trending Tags

    • Market Stories
    • Bitcoin
    • Litecoin
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Property
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Nigerian Model Oma Osele Wins Miss Continental World 2026 Crown

    Nigerian Model Oma Osele Wins Miss Continental World 2026 Crown

    ‘Career and Motherhood Can Coexist,’ Eugenia Abu Urges Women To Build Families Early 

    ‘Career and Motherhood Can Coexist,’ Eugenia Abu Urges Women To Build Families Early 

    Babatunde Adeyemo: Celebrating a Visionary Leader, Philanthropist and Real Estate Champion on His Birthday

    Babatunde Adeyemo: Celebrating a Visionary Leader, Philanthropist and Real Estate Champion on His Birthday

    Amaka Okeke Denies Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action Against Accusers

    Amaka Okeke Denies Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action Against Accusers

    Tega Breaks Silence Over Alleged Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action

    Tega Breaks Silence Over Alleged Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action

    Trending Tags

    • Bitcoin
    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Harbolnas
  • Entertainment
    ‘Stop Defaming Me Or Face Court Action,’ Toyin Abraham Threatens Warns Bloggers, Influencers Over ‘False’ Claims

    ‘Stop Defaming Me Or Face Court Action,’ Toyin Abraham Threatens Warns Bloggers, Influencers Over ‘False’ Claims

    Singer Felix Duke Arraigned Over Alleged N21.25m Fraud, Gets N10m Bail

    Singer Felix Duke Arraigned Over Alleged N21.25m Fraud, Gets N10m Bail

    “I Could Not Mourn My Husband” — Gbenga Adeboye’s Widow Breaks Silence, Reignites 23-Year Family Feud

    “I Could Not Mourn My Husband” — Gbenga Adeboye’s Widow Breaks Silence, Reignites 23-Year Family Feud

    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Ex-Adult Film Star Cindy In Tears, Says ‘I Regret Everything I’ve Done’

    Ex-Adult Film Star Cindy In Tears, Says ‘I Regret Everything I’ve Done’

    D’banj Pours Out His Heart in Emotional Tribute to Late Son – ‘Daddy Loves You Specially’

    D’banj Pours Out His Heart in Emotional Tribute to Late Son – ‘Daddy Loves You Specially’

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Explore Bali
    • Champions League
    • Harbolnas
  • Sports
    Palace Sack Sage After 3-1 Anfield Rout as Liverpool Hammer Final Nail

    Palace Sack Sage After 3-1 Anfield Rout as Liverpool Hammer Final Nail

    Tinubu To Flamingos: You Promised The Trophy, You Kept It — Nigeria Is Proud Of You

    Tinubu To Flamingos: You Promised The Trophy, You Kept It — Nigeria Is Proud Of You

    History Made! Flamingos Beat Japan 2-1 To Win Nigeria’s First U-17 Women’s World Cup

    History Made! Flamingos Beat Japan 2-1 To Win Nigeria’s First U-17 Women’s World Cup

    Tinubu to Flamingos: Go and Bring the Cup Home – ‘Nigeria is Proud of You’

    Tinubu to Flamingos: Go and Bring the Cup Home – ‘Nigeria is Proud of You’

    Tenerife Striker Jesus de Miguel, 30, Dies After Horror Collision With Goalkeeper

    Tenerife Striker Jesus de Miguel, 30, Dies After Horror Collision With Goalkeeper

    Kane Ends 25-Year Wait, Crowned 2026 Ballon d’Or King

    Kane Ends 25-Year Wait, Crowned 2026 Ballon d’Or King

    Trending Tags

    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Market Stories
    • Litecoin
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Crucible
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
    Binance Buys Back Tokens After $6.3bn Loss in History’s Biggest Heist Linked to North Korean Hackers

    Binance Buys Back Tokens After $6.3bn Loss in History’s Biggest Heist Linked to North Korean Hackers

    Dangote Group Eyes $36bn Revenue as Lamu Refinery Project Advances

    Dangote Group Eyes $36bn Revenue as Lamu Refinery Project Advances

    Don’t Use School Fees or Sell Your House to Buy Dangote Refinery Shares, Emir Sanusi Warns Nigerians

    Don’t Use School Fees or Sell Your House to Buy Dangote Refinery Shares, Emir Sanusi Warns Nigerians

    SEC Warns Investors as Dangote Refinery Opens N2.15tn Share Offer

    SEC Warns Investors as Dangote Refinery Opens N2.15tn Share Offer

    Johnson & Johnson Offers $5.5bn to End 69,000 Lawsuits Over Claims Baby Powder Caused Ovarian Cancer

    Johnson & Johnson Offers $5.5bn to End 69,000 Lawsuits Over Claims Baby Powder Caused Ovarian Cancer

    Lafarge Africa Rebrands As HBM Nigeria Plc, Signals New Era Under Huaxin Ownership

    Lafarge Africa Rebrands As HBM Nigeria Plc, Signals New Era Under Huaxin Ownership

    Trending Tags

    • Market Stories
    • Bitcoin
    • Litecoin
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Property
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Nigerian Model Oma Osele Wins Miss Continental World 2026 Crown

    Nigerian Model Oma Osele Wins Miss Continental World 2026 Crown

    ‘Career and Motherhood Can Coexist,’ Eugenia Abu Urges Women To Build Families Early 

    ‘Career and Motherhood Can Coexist,’ Eugenia Abu Urges Women To Build Families Early 

    Babatunde Adeyemo: Celebrating a Visionary Leader, Philanthropist and Real Estate Champion on His Birthday

    Babatunde Adeyemo: Celebrating a Visionary Leader, Philanthropist and Real Estate Champion on His Birthday

    Amaka Okeke Denies Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action Against Accusers

    Amaka Okeke Denies Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action Against Accusers

    Tega Breaks Silence Over Alleged Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action

    Tega Breaks Silence Over Alleged Affair With Frank Edoho, Threatens Legal Action

    Trending Tags

    • Bitcoin
    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Harbolnas
  • Entertainment
    ‘Stop Defaming Me Or Face Court Action,’ Toyin Abraham Threatens Warns Bloggers, Influencers Over ‘False’ Claims

    ‘Stop Defaming Me Or Face Court Action,’ Toyin Abraham Threatens Warns Bloggers, Influencers Over ‘False’ Claims

    Singer Felix Duke Arraigned Over Alleged N21.25m Fraud, Gets N10m Bail

    Singer Felix Duke Arraigned Over Alleged N21.25m Fraud, Gets N10m Bail

    “I Could Not Mourn My Husband” — Gbenga Adeboye’s Widow Breaks Silence, Reignites 23-Year Family Feud

    “I Could Not Mourn My Husband” — Gbenga Adeboye’s Widow Breaks Silence, Reignites 23-Year Family Feud

    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Shocking! Modupe Ozolua Discovers Five – Decade Secret in Bombshell Memoir

    Ex-Adult Film Star Cindy In Tears, Says ‘I Regret Everything I’ve Done’

    Ex-Adult Film Star Cindy In Tears, Says ‘I Regret Everything I’ve Done’

    D’banj Pours Out His Heart in Emotional Tribute to Late Son – ‘Daddy Loves You Specially’

    D’banj Pours Out His Heart in Emotional Tribute to Late Son – ‘Daddy Loves You Specially’

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Explore Bali
    • Champions League
    • Harbolnas
  • Sports
    Palace Sack Sage After 3-1 Anfield Rout as Liverpool Hammer Final Nail

    Palace Sack Sage After 3-1 Anfield Rout as Liverpool Hammer Final Nail

    Tinubu To Flamingos: You Promised The Trophy, You Kept It — Nigeria Is Proud Of You

    Tinubu To Flamingos: You Promised The Trophy, You Kept It — Nigeria Is Proud Of You

    History Made! Flamingos Beat Japan 2-1 To Win Nigeria’s First U-17 Women’s World Cup

    History Made! Flamingos Beat Japan 2-1 To Win Nigeria’s First U-17 Women’s World Cup

    Tinubu to Flamingos: Go and Bring the Cup Home – ‘Nigeria is Proud of You’

    Tinubu to Flamingos: Go and Bring the Cup Home – ‘Nigeria is Proud of You’

    Tenerife Striker Jesus de Miguel, 30, Dies After Horror Collision With Goalkeeper

    Tenerife Striker Jesus de Miguel, 30, Dies After Horror Collision With Goalkeeper

    Kane Ends 25-Year Wait, Crowned 2026 Ballon d’Or King

    Kane Ends 25-Year Wait, Crowned 2026 Ballon d’Or King

    Trending Tags

    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Market Stories
    • Litecoin
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Crucible
No Result
View All Result
Home News

When False Publications May Amount To Criminal Libel

The Daily Crucible by The Daily Crucible
December 5, 2024
in News
0
When False Publications May Amount To Criminal Libel

You might also like

2027: Human Rights Group Tasks INEC Chairman On Credible, Violence-Free Polls

Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Defence Plan To End 17-Year Insecurity, Says 15,000 Terrorists Killed

Okpebholo, Obaseki Trade Words Over Alleged N8bn Diversion

Criminal Libel may be a criminal offence as well as a civil wrong because of its tendency to provoke a breach of the peace. An indictment will lie (1) where the libel tends to provoke the person defamed to commit a breach of the peace; or (2) where it is in the public interest that criminal proceedings should be brought. Hence, publication to the person defamed may support a criminal prosecution but not a civil action. The prosecution is not bound to prove that the libel is unusually likely to provoke a breach of the peace

 

By Aare Afe Babalola SAN

In recent times, there has been an increase in the arrest and arraignment of persons alleged to have published false and misleading information against public figures. The first of these was that of a blogger who was arrested, arraigned and subsequently remanded in prison in connection to publication relating to a cleric. Since then there have more of such incidents including journalists of main stream media outlets.

 

Understandably, these arrests have attracted scrutiny from the public. While some have condemned what they see as highhandedness on the part of the complainants who in most cases are elected government officials, some have argued that the right to freedom of speech comes with a responsibility to keep within the law and that anyone who fails to keep within accepted boundaries must be subjected to the law.

 

However, most notably has been the perspective that the complainants should simply have filed civil actions against those they claim to have peddled wrong and injurious information concerning them. Those who hold this view argue, albeit wrongly, that such false and injurious publications give rise only to a right of action in a civil claim. It is for this reason that I intend to briefly highlight the fact that the publication of false and misleading information can give rise to criminal prosecution. In doing so it is not my intention to validate the various prosecutions that are ongoing or to suggest that such prosecutions are always the best way of dealing with wrongful and misleading publications. Rather it is my aim to draw the attention of stakeholders, particularly members of the fourth estate of the realm, to the fact that certain actions may bring them on a collision course with the law so that they may accordingly be guided in the exercise of their profession.

DEFAMATION CAN BE CIVIL AND CRIMINAL

Although tortuous defamation is the more common and more widely discussed, defamation is a dual-nature offence and it can be a civil wrong and as well a criminal act.

In its civil form, defamation seeks to protect for a man during his life-time the untainted possession of his reputation and good name. It is therefore a wrongful act in the eyes of the law for a man to directly impress in the mind of another person a matter that is not only untrue but is likely in the ordinary and natural course of things to substantially injure the reputation of a third party. This is what is called defamation and in tort may attract the award of damages in favour of the person wronged.

However, defamation can also be a criminal wrong for which an offender can be charged, prosecuted, convicted and sentenced. And this form of defamation is the concern of this paper.

In criminal defamation, the law seeks to prevent a situation in which defamation assumes a tendency to arouse angry passion, provoke revenge and set the society ablaze in a way that public peace is endangered.

Defamation is generally of two kinds: if it is published in a transient, fugitive form, it is called slander. A permanent publication, printed or written, of a false and injurious material against another person, whether it be in painting or picture, effigy, caricature, advertisement, article, news report, talking film or any disparaging object will qualify as libel.

Broadcasting, including sound and television aimed for general reaction is a publication in permanent form and therefore libel.

As noted, personal squabbles between individuals should not find their way into the criminal docket of any court. Thus the Police should not lend themselves to an abuse of the judicial system by rushing to prosecute any journalist on account only of the fact that he has published a story which a governor or some other government official does not agree with. The proper step in such instances is for the government to put forward its own narrative regarding the subject of the publication

Publication is important in defamation, whether tortuous or criminal. Section 374 of the Criminal Code Law defines the publication of a defamatory matter as being:

“a) in the case of spoken words or credible sounds, the speaking of such words or the making of such sounds in the hearing of the person defamed or nay other person;

“b) in other cases, the exhibiting it in public, or causing it to be read or seen, or showing or delivering it, or causing it to be shown or delivered, with intent that it may be read or seen by the person defamed or by any other person”.

The above definition of instances of publication in the crime of defamation shows a clear difference in the conception of publication in the tort of defamation. Whereas in tort the false publication must be to a third party before it is taken as defamatory, in the crime of defamation, however, publication to the person defamed alone is enough.

Criminal Libel may be a criminal offence as well as a civil wrong because of its tendency to provoke a breach of the peace. An indictment will lie (1) where the libel tends to provoke the person defamed to commit a breach of the peace; or (2) where it is in the public interest that criminal proceedings should be brought. Hence, publication to the person defamed may support a criminal prosecution but not a civil action. The prosecution is not bound to prove that the libel is unusually likely to provoke a breach of the peace.

At common law the truth of defamatory matter was not a defence to a prosecution for criminal libel, but this is no longer so if, in addition to the truth of the defamatory matter, the defendant can also establish that its publication was for the public benefit.

Before criminal proceedings in respect of a libel, are instituted, there must be a case to go before a criminal court that is so clear at first sight that it is beyond argument that there is a case to answer. Secondly, the libel must be a serious one, so serious that it is proper for the criminal law to be invoked. It may be a relevant factor that it is unusually likely for the libel to provoke a breach of the peace, although that is not a necessary ingredient at all. Thirdly, the question of the public interest must be taken into account, so that the judge has to ask himself the question: ‘Does the public interest require the institution of criminal proceedings? Once the Attorney General arrives at the conclusion that the criminal law ought to be invoked, then it is not a private case between individual: the state has an interest and the state has a part in it.

The highly respected Lord Coleridge CJ had this to say on public interest;

There ought to be some public interest concerned, something affecting the Crown or the guardians of the public peace (likely to be broken by the alleged libel), to justify the recourse by a private person to a criminal remedy by way of indictment. If, either by reason of the continued repetition or infamous character of the libel, breach of the peace is likely to ensure, then the libeler should be indicted; but, in the absence of any such conditions, a personal squabble between two private individuals ought not to be permitted by grand juries, as indeed, it is not permitted by sound law, to b the subject of a criminal indictment”.

The above is essentially the principle that should guide the decision to institute criminal libel cases in Nigeria. As noted, personal squabbles between individuals should not find their way into the criminal docket of any court. Thus the Police should not lend themselves to an abuse of the judicial system by rushing to prosecute any journalist on account only of the fact that he has published a story which a governor or some other government official does not agree with. The proper step in such instances is for the government to put forward its own narrative regarding the subject of the publication. It is for this reason that most governors surround themselves with Press aides. However, those who make publications should also take extra effort to authenticate the sources of their stories. In a country such as ours with a history of violence brought about by misleading information, the duty becomes even more important. In this regard, I note that there are current efforts to stem the tide of fake news in the mainstream and online media. There are now platforms dedicated to fact checking claims made in publications. In the wake of the last xenophobic attacks on Nigerians in South Africa, a popular blogger reported that the office of a South African owned telecommunications company in Lagos had been set on fire. However the falsity of the publication was quickly spotted and reported as the picture of a burning office included in it was identified as that of a fire incident that occurred years earlier. These efforts must continue. It is in the interest of all that peace endures in Nigeria.

AARE AFE BABALOLA, OFR, CON, SAN, LL.D, Founder/President, ABUAD. Olusegun Obasanjo Way, Ado Ekiti 360102, Ekiti, Nigeria.

Source:https://www.abuad.edu.ng/when-false-publications-may-amount-to-criminal-libel/

•Opinions, thoughts or positions expressed here are personal and strictly of the writer/author and not The Daily Crucible.
Previous Post

Senator Adeola YAYI Is An Original Son Of Ogun West Who Has Added Unprecedented Value To The District – Aide

Next Post

Giving Girl Child Education Is the Best Thing To Do – Sultan of Sokoto

The Daily Crucible

The Daily Crucible

The Daily Crucible Newspaper is an authoritative independent online news medium established to deliver professional journalism for the purpose of fostering Nigeria's unity, progress and greatness, given the heterogeneity of her citizens. We shall vigorously pursue this vision and anchor it on tripod of truth, justice and fairness. We shall feed the public with robust information they need to make informed decision on issues and matters that affect them, promote human - capital development, freedom and free market enterprise. Our loyalty shall be to Nigeria and public interest, and shall respect ethnic, religious and political diversity without being partisan and sectional.

Related Posts

2027: Human Rights Group Tasks INEC Chairman On Credible, Violence-Free Polls
News

2027: Human Rights Group Tasks INEC Chairman On Credible, Violence-Free Polls

by The Daily Crucible
November 15, 2026
Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Defence Plan To End 17-Year Insecurity, Says 15,000 Terrorists Killed
News

Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Defence Plan To End 17-Year Insecurity, Says 15,000 Terrorists Killed

by The Daily Crucible
November 15, 2026
Okpebholo, Obaseki Trade Words Over Alleged N8bn Diversion
News

Okpebholo, Obaseki Trade Words Over Alleged N8bn Diversion

by The Daily Crucible
November 15, 2026
NGE Demands Immediate Release of Detained Investigative Journalist, Daniel Ojukwu
News

NGE Demands Immediate Release of Detained Investigative Journalist, Daniel Ojukwu

by The Daily Crucible
November 15, 2026
Nigerian ‘Worst Landlord’ in US Owes $450,000 As His Collapsed Brooklyn Building Kills 8
News

Nigerian ‘Worst Landlord’ in US Owes $450,000 As His Collapsed Brooklyn Building Kills 8

by The Daily Crucible
November 15, 2026
Next Post
Giving Girl Child Education Is the Best Thing To Do – Sultan of Sokoto

Giving Girl Child Education Is the Best Thing To Do – Sultan of Sokoto

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

No Result
View All Result

Advertisement

Advertisement

Recent News

2027: Human Rights Group Tasks INEC Chairman On Credible, Violence-Free Polls

2027: Human Rights Group Tasks INEC Chairman On Credible, Violence-Free Polls

November 15, 2026
Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Defence Plan To End 17-Year Insecurity, Says 15,000 Terrorists Killed

Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Defence Plan To End 17-Year Insecurity, Says 15,000 Terrorists Killed

November 15, 2026
Okpebholo, Obaseki Trade Words Over Alleged N8bn Diversion

Okpebholo, Obaseki Trade Words Over Alleged N8bn Diversion

November 15, 2026
NGE Demands Immediate Release of Detained Investigative Journalist, Daniel Ojukwu

NGE Demands Immediate Release of Detained Investigative Journalist, Daniel Ojukwu

November 15, 2026
The Burden of National Identity: Diaspora Responsibility and the International Reputation of the Nigerian State

The Burden of National Identity: Diaspora Responsibility and the International Reputation of the Nigerian State

November 15, 2026
Nigerian ‘Worst Landlord’ in US Owes $450,000 As His Collapsed Brooklyn Building Kills 8

Nigerian ‘Worst Landlord’ in US Owes $450,000 As His Collapsed Brooklyn Building Kills 8

November 15, 2026
Booing The President

Booing The President

November 15, 2026
Three Security Operatives to Face Interrogation Over Kano Governor’s Second Wife Divorce Crisis

Three Security Operatives to Face Interrogation Over Kano Governor’s Second Wife Divorce Crisis

November 15, 2026
Akeem Amosun: From Boardroom to Frontline of Grassroots Push for Yayi’s 2027 Project

Akeem Amosun: From Boardroom to Frontline of Grassroots Push for Yayi’s 2027 Project

November 15, 2026
South-East Risks Prolonged Political Isolation If It Makes Wrong Choices In 2027 – Mbah

South-East Risks Prolonged Political Isolation If It Makes Wrong Choices In 2027 – Mbah

November 15, 2026
The Daily Crucible

The Daily Crucible Newspaper is an authoritative and independent online news medium established to deliver professional journalism for the purpose of fostering Nigeria's unity, peace, progress, and greatness, given the heterogeneity of its citizens.

© 2022 The Daily Crucible - Designed by CYBERWARRIOR.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Property
  • Business
  • Education
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • About Us

© 2022 The Daily Crucible - Designed by CYBERWARRIOR.