Saturday, July 12, 2025
  • About Us
  • Advertisement
  • Privacy Policy
The Daily Crucible
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
    BRICS Summit: Tinubu Seeks Reevaluation Of Global Governance, Finance, Healthcare 

    BRICS Summit: Tinubu Seeks Reevaluation Of Global Governance, Finance, Healthcare 

    Tinubu In Brazil For BRICS Meeting, To Woo Investors 

    Tinubu In Brazil For BRICS Meeting, To Woo Investors 

    AMCON Sells 60% Stake In Ibadan DisCo For N100bn

    AMCON Sells 60% Stake In Ibadan DisCo For N100bn

    Lagos Bans Real Estate Practice, Others Without LASRERA Certification

    Lagos Bans Real Estate Practice, Others Without LASRERA Certification

    ICYMI: President Tinubu Confers GCON on Outgoing Afrexim Bank Chairman, Benedict Oramah

    ICYMI: President Tinubu Confers GCON on Outgoing Afrexim Bank Chairman, Benedict Oramah

    FG Gives N60B To Gombe For Agro-Livestock Industrial Zone

    FG Gives N60B To Gombe For Agro-Livestock Industrial Zone

    Trending Tags

    • Market Stories
    • Bitcoin
    • Litecoin
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Property
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
    ‘Meeting President Tinubu and Prime Minister Pierre Is a Very Inspiring Moment For Me’ – Nigerian Medical Student In Saint Lucia 

    ‘Meeting President Tinubu and Prime Minister Pierre Is a Very Inspiring Moment For Me’ – Nigerian Medical Student In Saint Lucia 

    Amosun’s Wife, Other Descendants of Ogunbona Agboketoyinbo Mark 164th Memorial of their Revered Egba Warlord

    Amosun’s Wife, Other Descendants of Ogunbona Agboketoyinbo Mark 164th Memorial of their Revered Egba Warlord

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    Surveyor Haleemat Oluwatoyin Yusuf’s Day Of Double Celebration 

    Surveyor Haleemat Oluwatoyin Yusuf’s Day Of Double Celebration 

    Giant Of African Literature Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o Departs At 87

    Giant Of African Literature Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o Departs At 87

    If Akeredolu Had Listened To Me, I Wouldn’t Be a Widow, Laments Ex – Governor’s Wife, Betty

    If Akeredolu Had Listened To Me, I Wouldn’t Be a Widow, Laments Ex – Governor’s Wife, Betty

    Trending Tags

    • Bitcoin
    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Harbolnas
  • Entertainment
    ‘Ireke: Rise of the Maroons’ Set for Debut July 25

    ‘Ireke: Rise of the Maroons’ Set for Debut July 25

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    Tinubu, Gov Mbah Mourn Nonagenarian Highlife Music Icon Ejeagha

    Tinubu, Gov Mbah Mourn Nonagenarian Highlife Music Icon Ejeagha

    Drug Cartel Members Abdúct, Kíll 5 Musicians On Way To Concert Venue

    Drug Cartel Members Abdúct, Kíll 5 Musicians On Way To Concert Venue

    I’m Still Saving My Virginity – Actress Olayode

    I’m Still Saving My Virginity – Actress Olayode

    My Ultimate Vision Is To Elevate African Sounds On the Global Stage – Ebonny Musik

    My Ultimate Vision Is To Elevate African Sounds On the Global Stage – Ebonny Musik

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Explore Bali
    • Champions League
    • Harbolnas
  • Sports
    NSF Tragedy: Abiodun Mourns, Sends Delegation To Kano, Supports Victims’ Families With N31m

    NSF Tragedy: Abiodun Mourns, Sends Delegation To Kano, Supports Victims’ Families With N31m

    Gateway Games: Protesting Ogun Athletes Lift Siege At Games Village

    Gateway Games: Protesting Ogun Athletes Lift Siege At Games Village

    Gateway Games Activities Grounded As Ogun Athletes Protest Over Unpaid Allowance

    Gateway Games Activities Grounded As Ogun Athletes Protest Over Unpaid Allowance

    Odogbolu Leads As First Local Govt To Adopt eSports

    Odogbolu Leads As First Local Govt To Adopt eSports

    Gateway Games: Athletes, Spectators Flee As Gas Explosion Rocks Alake Sports Complex

    Gateway Games: Athletes, Spectators Flee As Gas Explosion Rocks Alake Sports Complex

    Gateway Games: NSC Disqualifies 6 Athletes Over Alleged Doping Issues

    Gateway Games: NSC Disqualifies 6 Athletes Over Alleged Doping Issues

    Trending Tags

    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Market Stories
    • Litecoin
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Crucible
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
    BRICS Summit: Tinubu Seeks Reevaluation Of Global Governance, Finance, Healthcare 

    BRICS Summit: Tinubu Seeks Reevaluation Of Global Governance, Finance, Healthcare 

    Tinubu In Brazil For BRICS Meeting, To Woo Investors 

    Tinubu In Brazil For BRICS Meeting, To Woo Investors 

    AMCON Sells 60% Stake In Ibadan DisCo For N100bn

    AMCON Sells 60% Stake In Ibadan DisCo For N100bn

    Lagos Bans Real Estate Practice, Others Without LASRERA Certification

    Lagos Bans Real Estate Practice, Others Without LASRERA Certification

    ICYMI: President Tinubu Confers GCON on Outgoing Afrexim Bank Chairman, Benedict Oramah

    ICYMI: President Tinubu Confers GCON on Outgoing Afrexim Bank Chairman, Benedict Oramah

    FG Gives N60B To Gombe For Agro-Livestock Industrial Zone

    FG Gives N60B To Gombe For Agro-Livestock Industrial Zone

    Trending Tags

    • Market Stories
    • Bitcoin
    • Litecoin
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Property
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
    ‘Meeting President Tinubu and Prime Minister Pierre Is a Very Inspiring Moment For Me’ – Nigerian Medical Student In Saint Lucia 

    ‘Meeting President Tinubu and Prime Minister Pierre Is a Very Inspiring Moment For Me’ – Nigerian Medical Student In Saint Lucia 

    Amosun’s Wife, Other Descendants of Ogunbona Agboketoyinbo Mark 164th Memorial of their Revered Egba Warlord

    Amosun’s Wife, Other Descendants of Ogunbona Agboketoyinbo Mark 164th Memorial of their Revered Egba Warlord

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    Surveyor Haleemat Oluwatoyin Yusuf’s Day Of Double Celebration 

    Surveyor Haleemat Oluwatoyin Yusuf’s Day Of Double Celebration 

    Giant Of African Literature Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o Departs At 87

    Giant Of African Literature Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o Departs At 87

    If Akeredolu Had Listened To Me, I Wouldn’t Be a Widow, Laments Ex – Governor’s Wife, Betty

    If Akeredolu Had Listened To Me, I Wouldn’t Be a Widow, Laments Ex – Governor’s Wife, Betty

    Trending Tags

    • Bitcoin
    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Harbolnas
  • Entertainment
    ‘Ireke: Rise of the Maroons’ Set for Debut July 25

    ‘Ireke: Rise of the Maroons’ Set for Debut July 25

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    ‘Steeze,’ Glamour As Ijebu Celebrates Ojude Oba Cultural Carnival

    Tinubu, Gov Mbah Mourn Nonagenarian Highlife Music Icon Ejeagha

    Tinubu, Gov Mbah Mourn Nonagenarian Highlife Music Icon Ejeagha

    Drug Cartel Members Abdúct, Kíll 5 Musicians On Way To Concert Venue

    Drug Cartel Members Abdúct, Kíll 5 Musicians On Way To Concert Venue

    I’m Still Saving My Virginity – Actress Olayode

    I’m Still Saving My Virginity – Actress Olayode

    My Ultimate Vision Is To Elevate African Sounds On the Global Stage – Ebonny Musik

    My Ultimate Vision Is To Elevate African Sounds On the Global Stage – Ebonny Musik

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes 2018
    • Grammy Awards
    • Explore Bali
    • Champions League
    • Harbolnas
  • Sports
    NSF Tragedy: Abiodun Mourns, Sends Delegation To Kano, Supports Victims’ Families With N31m

    NSF Tragedy: Abiodun Mourns, Sends Delegation To Kano, Supports Victims’ Families With N31m

    Gateway Games: Protesting Ogun Athletes Lift Siege At Games Village

    Gateway Games: Protesting Ogun Athletes Lift Siege At Games Village

    Gateway Games Activities Grounded As Ogun Athletes Protest Over Unpaid Allowance

    Gateway Games Activities Grounded As Ogun Athletes Protest Over Unpaid Allowance

    Odogbolu Leads As First Local Govt To Adopt eSports

    Odogbolu Leads As First Local Govt To Adopt eSports

    Gateway Games: Athletes, Spectators Flee As Gas Explosion Rocks Alake Sports Complex

    Gateway Games: Athletes, Spectators Flee As Gas Explosion Rocks Alake Sports Complex

    Gateway Games: NSC Disqualifies 6 Athletes Over Alleged Doping Issues

    Gateway Games: NSC Disqualifies 6 Athletes Over Alleged Doping Issues

    Trending Tags

    • Champions League
    • Explore Bali
    • Harbolnas
    • United Stated
    • Market Stories
    • Litecoin
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Crucible
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Osun Guber: Declare Me Winner – Oyetola Tells Tribunal As Panel Reserves Judgement Date 

The Daily Crucible by The Daily Crucible
January 14, 2023
in News
0

Osun Election Tribunal sitting in Osogbo, led by Justice Tetsea Kume, on Friday admitted the written addresses of the parties involved in the litigation, after the counsel for All Progressives Congress, APC, Adegboyega Oyetola, and those of Senator Ademola Adeleke, the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP and the Independent National Electoral Commission, INEC, argued and adopted their final written addresses before the Tribunal.

This is even as Counsel for Oyetola insisted that Senator Adeleke submitted forged certificates, having submitted a Testimonial purported to have been issued by Ede Muslim Grammar School, bearing Osun State at a time Osun had not been created and another letter of Attestation from Ede Muslim High School, to indicate he attended a secondary school.

You might also like

Over 90 Benefit From Free Surgeries In Ogun As US – based Naykas Healthcare Targets 200

NAF Bombs Convoy Of Over 300 Terrorists Heading To Zamfara, Kílls Scores

NCS Intercepts 40ft Container Load Of Donkey Genitals On Kaduna–Abuja Expressway

The petitioners insisted that if the governor had indeed attended Ede Muslim Grammar School, he could not have presented an Attestation Letter from Ede Muslim High School to show he attended a secondary school.

Making their submissions before the Tribunal, Counsel for Oyetola and APC, led by Prince Lateef Fagbemi, SAN, noted that the mere fact that INEC did not at any stage indicate that the CTC BVAS report issued to the petitioners was a temporary one or an unsynchronised one, the Tribunal should accept it as the best evidence in the circumstances, adding that the second CTC BVAS report issued to the PDP and Senator Adeleke by INEC was an afterthought, especially because it was sought after the petitioners had filed their petition before the Tribunal.

Prince Fagbemi went further to submit that even in the CTC BVAS report issued to the PDP and Senator Adeleke, there were infractions in over 100 polling units. He therefore urged the Tribunal to declare Oyetola as the winner of the election, after canceling votes from the disputed polling units.

In his own argument, Counsel for INEC, Prof. Paul Ananaba, submitted that there were discrepancies in 1,750 polling units, saying that results of elections are updated on a continuous basis.

He said as at the time the first CTC BVAS report was issued to the petitioners, some “data were still hanging” and that it was the second CTC BVAS report which was synchronised that should be relied upon by the Tribunal.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is even as Counsel for Adeleke Onyeachi Ikpeazu disowned INEC’s second CTC BVAS report, a document relied upon by INEC at the Tribunal to defend its declaration of Senator Adeleke as the winner of the July 16 governorship election.

 

Arguing his submission before the Tribunal, Fagbemi said: “I state that it is only Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) that is given statutory responsibility to conduct election. I submit that where there is allegation on conduct of election, it is only INEC that has the responsibility to show otherwise.

 

” The grouse of the petitioners with respect to these grounds, are on the conduct of the election. I submit further that the attempt by 2nd Respondent to discredit Exhibit R.BVR should be discountenance as stated by the 2nd respondent (Adeleke.)

 

“I submit that we are in a completely new electoral dispensation, unless we know this, we will just be wallowing. I started with concept of over-voting, is different in the present legal regime from the previous legal regime.

 

“Section 51(2) of Electrical Act, defines over-voting and this clearly is different from the position of Section 33 of the 2011 Electoral Act. Section 47 (2) of the 2022 Electoral Act read together with Clause 20 of the regulation of conduct of election (Exhibit 1) makes the use of BVAS and not Voters’ Register mandatory in order to determine Accredited Voters.

 

“I submit that Exhibit 2R.RW2 in paragraph 1.2, did not mention any Voter’s Register as part of the documents he used and I submit that witness did not consider it necessary hence his refusal to state that he used same.

“Section 64 (4) of Electoral Act 2022 is the provision of the law that requires the collation by the presiding officer to be satisfied by the number of accredited voters. I submit that the concept of synchronisation is unknown to the Electoral Laws. What it recognises is that where a voter not recognised by the BVAS machine, such a voter will not be allowed to vote. The only occasion where merger of data occurs on two BVAS machines is when two BVAS machines were used at a polling unit and they must be used or done at polling unit level – see paragraph of Exhibits.

“I submit that there was no report of any merger of any BVAS machine data used at polling unit at the election contest. I submit that INEC did not state any date in their pleadings that they used more than one BVAS machine in any polling. The intention of the law i.e Section 64 (4)(a) of the 2022 Electoral Act is that the number of accredited voters must have been ascertained before the declaration of results.

“I submit that under the 2022 Electoral Act, no time was stated for INEC to declare results. I submit that all the parties were unanimous on the date of election that took place on 16th of July, 2022 and declaration of results on 17th July, 2022 and issuance of Certificate of Return to the 2nd Respondent on 20th of July, 2022.

“The question therefore is on what details of accredited voters did INEC did all above? I further submit that RW1 stated in evidence that she issued and certified Exhibit R.BVR and as such, presumption of regularity endures in favour of the Exhibit. The 1st Respondent did not notify the petitioners of any irregularities as same was not recalled by the 1st Respondent.

“I submit that it was after service of the petition on the Respondent that they now resort to an afterthought concept of synchronisation. I submit that if the tribunal allows the concept of synchronisation, it will act to a point that it is INEC and not the electorate that determine the outcome of an election – see paragraph 7.33 to 7.39 of our Final Written Address,” Fagbemi added.

On the issue of Certificate Forgery, the Petitioners’ Counsel argued that “the testimonial shows on its face that or was issued in Osun State in 1988 a whole 3 years before Osun State came into existence. They should have pleaded that they made an error or mistake but that was never done.

“The Judgment of Court of Appeal that I said, they did not prove their case, there is nothing from the Respondent to contradict our evidence. So, the documents tendered in this regards by the witness of the 2nd Respondent (Adeleke) are mere hearsay. When you have no connection to a certificate, you are not the one that issued it, that he was given, the law says ‘No’ to such documents.

“It has no probative value. Any document showing that Osun State is in existence since 1988 is clearly false. Supreme Court says ‘where only document shows it is false, it is clearly false.”

On his part, Counsel for Adeleke, Ikpeazu SAN noted that a clear distinction ought to be maintained between back-end server and the Certified Copy of the extraction from the BVAS machines.

“Contrary to the submission of the Petitioners, RWl confirmed a physical inspection of the BVAS based on the Order of Court for same to be extracted. It is on this pedestal that the case of the 2nd Respondent (Adeleke) was mounted.

“2nd Respondent (Adeleke) is not bound by the case of the 1st Respondent (INEC) which was found as the second BVAS report which was labelled synchronised but which was not a comprehensive one from the BVAS machines themselves.

“The 2nd Respondent (Adeleke) is not bound by evidence led by the 1st Respondent (INEC) which is an independent body. The second Respondent presented a unique case which is founded based on Evidence Rule by relying on the physical and primary source of all capture of accreditations that were made on the day of the election itself.”

After listening to all the arguments, the Tribunal rose at exactly 7. 30pm and adjourned for judgement on a date it said would be communicated to all parties.

Previous Post

We Won’t Handover ‘Sick’ Nigeria To A Quack Doctor, Kinsman Replies Peter Obi

Next Post

10 Die As Bus Rams Into Truck On Lagos – Ibadan Expressway

The Daily Crucible

The Daily Crucible

The Daily Crucible Newspaper is an authoritative and independent online news medium established to deliver professional journalism for the purpose of fostering Nigeria's unity, peace, progress and greatness, given the heterogeneity of her citizens. We shall vigorously pursue this vision and anchor it on tripod of truth, justice and fairness. We shall feed the general public with robust information they need to make informed decision on issues and matters that affect them, promote human - capital development, freedom and free market enterprise. And our loyalty shall be to Nigeria and public interest, and shall respect ethnic, religious and political diversity without being partisan and sectional.

Related Posts

Over 90 Benefit From Free Surgeries In Ogun As US – based Naykas Healthcare Targets 200
Health

Over 90 Benefit From Free Surgeries In Ogun As US – based Naykas Healthcare Targets 200

by The Daily Crucible
July 11, 2025
NAF Bombs Convoy Of Over 300 Terrorists Heading To Zamfara, Kílls Scores
News

NAF Bombs Convoy Of Over 300 Terrorists Heading To Zamfara, Kílls Scores

by The Daily Crucible
July 11, 2025
NCS Intercepts 40ft Container Load Of Donkey Genitals On Kaduna–Abuja Expressway
News

NCS Intercepts 40ft Container Load Of Donkey Genitals On Kaduna–Abuja Expressway

by The Daily Crucible
July 10, 2025
PDP’s Ighodalo Accepts Fate As Supreme Court Validates Okpebholo’s Victory 
News

PDP’s Ighodalo Accepts Fate As Supreme Court Validates Okpebholo’s Victory 

by The Daily Crucible
July 10, 2025
Supreme Court Dismisses Ighodalo’s Appeal, Affirms Senator Okpebholo As Edo Governor
News

Supreme Court Dismisses Ighodalo’s Appeal, Affirms Senator Okpebholo As Edo Governor

by The Daily Crucible
July 10, 2025
Next Post
10 Die As Bus Rams Into Truck On Lagos – Ibadan Expressway

10 Die As Bus Rams Into Truck On Lagos - Ibadan Expressway

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Our Eders, Please Tell Muritala Yakubu To Stop Disgracing US In Igalaland

Our Eders, Please Tell Muritala Yakubu To Stop Disgracing US In Igalaland

July 14, 2023
Ogun: FG/REA Builds 100kw Solar Powered Electricity For Eriwe Fish Farm Village

Ogun: FG/REA Builds 100kw Solar Powered Electricity For Eriwe Fish Farm Village

June 19, 2023

Categories

  • Business
  • Column
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Interview
  • Lifestyle
  • Metro
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Property
  • Sports
  • World

Don't miss it

Yoruba Ancestral Land, Joe Igbokwe And The ‘New Lagos Developers’
Opinion

Yoruba Ancestral Land, Joe Igbokwe And The ‘New Lagos Developers’

July 11, 2025
Over 90 Benefit From Free Surgeries In Ogun As US – based Naykas Healthcare Targets 200
Health

Over 90 Benefit From Free Surgeries In Ogun As US – based Naykas Healthcare Targets 200

July 11, 2025
NAF Bombs Convoy Of Over 300 Terrorists Heading To Zamfara, Kílls Scores
News

NAF Bombs Convoy Of Over 300 Terrorists Heading To Zamfara, Kílls Scores

July 11, 2025
NCS Intercepts 40ft Container Load Of Donkey Genitals On Kaduna–Abuja Expressway
News

NCS Intercepts 40ft Container Load Of Donkey Genitals On Kaduna–Abuja Expressway

July 10, 2025
PDP’s Ighodalo Accepts Fate As Supreme Court Validates Okpebholo’s Victory 
News

PDP’s Ighodalo Accepts Fate As Supreme Court Validates Okpebholo’s Victory 

July 10, 2025
Supreme Court Dismisses Ighodalo’s Appeal, Affirms Senator Okpebholo As Edo Governor
News

Supreme Court Dismisses Ighodalo’s Appeal, Affirms Senator Okpebholo As Edo Governor

July 10, 2025
The Daily Crucible

The Daily Crucible Newspaper is an authoritative and independent online news medium established to deliver professional journalism for the purpose of fostering Nigeria's unity, peace, progress, and greatness, given the heterogeneity of its citizens.

© 2022 The Daily Crucible - Designed by CYBERWARRIOR.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Property
  • Business
  • Education
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • About Us

© 2022 The Daily Crucible - Designed by CYBERWARRIOR.